Студопедия

КАТЕГОРИИ:


Архитектура-(3434)Астрономия-(809)Биология-(7483)Биотехнологии-(1457)Военное дело-(14632)Высокие технологии-(1363)География-(913)Геология-(1438)Государство-(451)Демография-(1065)Дом-(47672)Журналистика и СМИ-(912)Изобретательство-(14524)Иностранные языки-(4268)Информатика-(17799)Искусство-(1338)История-(13644)Компьютеры-(11121)Косметика-(55)Кулинария-(373)Культура-(8427)Лингвистика-(374)Литература-(1642)Маркетинг-(23702)Математика-(16968)Машиностроение-(1700)Медицина-(12668)Менеджмент-(24684)Механика-(15423)Науковедение-(506)Образование-(11852)Охрана труда-(3308)Педагогика-(5571)Полиграфия-(1312)Политика-(7869)Право-(5454)Приборостроение-(1369)Программирование-(2801)Производство-(97182)Промышленность-(8706)Психология-(18388)Религия-(3217)Связь-(10668)Сельское хозяйство-(299)Социология-(6455)Спорт-(42831)Строительство-(4793)Торговля-(5050)Транспорт-(2929)Туризм-(1568)Физика-(3942)Философия-(17015)Финансы-(26596)Химия-(22929)Экология-(12095)Экономика-(9961)Электроника-(8441)Электротехника-(4623)Энергетика-(12629)Юриспруденция-(1492)Ядерная техника-(1748)

Task 3. Review the text




Crimes and Punishments

“No punishment has ever possessed enough power of deterrence to prevent the commission of crimes. On the contrary, whatever the punishments, once a specific crime has appeared for the first time, its reappearance, is more likely than its initial emergence could have been.” (Hannah Arendt)

“The severity of the punishment must also be in keeping with the kind of obligation which has been violated, and not (only) with the interests of public security.” (Simone Weil)

On the television screen, a middle-aged woman is telling a reporter about the death of her daughter; her voice and facial expression oscillate between tremulous grief and controlled rage. Three years ago, on a spring evening, her twenty-year-old daughter was walking home from the bus stop after a day of college classes. A young man stopped her at knife point and demanded her purse; she gave it to him and then started to scream. He stabbed her in the chest. She was dead on arrival at the nearest hospital emergency room. Because there were several witnesses, the police were able to arrest the killer on the same night. Six months later, he pleaded guilty to a reduced charge of manslaughter and received a sentence of zero-to-seven years. In just thirty months, he was released from prison for good behaviour.

“I just can’t get over this”, says the slain girl’s mother. “I will never get over this. To know that the price of my child’s life was less than three years, that this man is free now to do the same thing to someone else – I can’t reconcile myself to it. I can’t believe any more that there is such a thing as justice in the world. Everything I tried to live by, everything I brought up my children to respect: things just don’t work that way.” The woman tells the reporter she is active in an organization for crime victims and their relatives. “We all know we have to get on with our lives,” she says, “but that isn’t easy to do under the circumstances. I felt as though my girl was killed twice - once by that scum, and once by the judge who said, well, you only have to go to jail for a few years. They killed her memory, saying that was all her life was worth.” The outraged mother spoke of justice, not revenge, but revenge was obviously one element in an ideal of justice to which she had adhered, without giving the matter much conscious thought, until the day when the issue was transformed from an abstraction into a painful personal reality. This sense of justice is so fundamental to our psychological well-being that it rarely intrudes upon our consciousness; like many basic assumptions, it remains largely unexamined unless and until it is sorely violated. The symbolic “scales of justice” have a real meaning for most citizens, who believe that the legal system exists to maintain a moral and social equilibrium, and to restore, the equilibrium when it has been violently disturbed.

There is, of course, a wide range of opinion on what constitutes appropriate redress. For those, whose concept of justice is concerned primarily with the criminal’s rights and prospects for rehabilitation, any extended punishment is simply another crime. For those focused totally on the victim’s rights, only executions or other severe penalties will suffice to restore a sense of moral balance. Between these extremes lies a broad concept of justice that demands a greater measure of retribution than the American legal system currently dispenses, a spectrum of retribution that excludes both execution and the release of a killer from prison in less than three years. This intermediate sense of justice – one that is, I believe, shared by the largest proportion of the public – has been outraged by the inadequate response of the legal system to the rising incidence of violent crime during the past twenty years. Such outrage is unquestionably the single most important factor in the emotional resurgence of support for capital punishment today; it must be addressed by those who refuse, as I do, to include death in their concept of retributive justice.

It is true that a measure of popular enthusiasm for the death penalty exists independently of the general level of crime arid violence in society. Otherwise, there would be no support for capital punishment in Western Europe, England, and Canada, whose crime rates make them appear as nearly pastoral realms in comparison to the United States. In view of the relatively greater personal safety they enjoy, it’s not surprising that those Europeans who favor capital punishment expend less passion on the issue than the Americans do.

A significant exception to this lack of passion is apparent when Europeans begin to talk about the need to “get tough” with perpetrators of political violence. The United States has been relatively unaffected by the kind of highly visible terrorist acts that have influenced public opinion in England, France, Italy and Germany. Even our most traumatic political assassinations have generally been; perceived as isolated acts rather than as full-scale ruptures in the fabric of society. This perception of violence as a phenomenon for which the instigators are personally and individually accountable reflects a characteristically American attitude that extends far beyond issues of crime and punishment. (Wild Justice by Susan Jacoby).


 

  UKRAINE  

 

Warming up:

1) What can you tell about Ukraine?

2) What outstanding people of Ukraine do you know?

3) What is the date of the proclamation of Independence of Ukraine?

 




Поделиться с друзьями:


Дата добавления: 2014-12-17; Просмотров: 586; Нарушение авторских прав?; Мы поможем в написании вашей работы!


Нам важно ваше мнение! Был ли полезен опубликованный материал? Да | Нет



studopedia.su - Студопедия (2013 - 2024) год. Все материалы представленные на сайте исключительно с целью ознакомления читателями и не преследуют коммерческих целей или нарушение авторских прав! Последнее добавление




Генерация страницы за: 0.014 сек.